In the June
5 "Explainer," Christopher Bonanos made several errors. First, he
stated that the pirate's "arrr" originated with Robert Newton. Lionel
Barrymore used "arrrgh" in a film from 1934. Second, he identified
Dorset as being in the Cotswolds district of southwest England. The
Cotswolds are in central England. Third, he asserted that most pirates
were from oppressed nations like Scotland and Ireland. Many were, but
more came from southwest England than anywhere else. Fourth, he stated
that "arrr" is "strictly fiction," and that no one ever walked the
plank. West country pirates may well have used the phrase "arrrgh," and
there does exist at least one recorded instance of plank-walking. Link