This ran in the Washington Post:
A Religion
News Service article that ran July 15 and recounted a story published
by the Forward newspaper about Agriprocessors Inc. contained several
inaccuracies that were not in the Forward's article.
The Forward's article reported on claims by workers and others of
abusive working conditions at the Postville, Iowa, slaughterhouse and
the company's denial of those claims.
The Forward and RNS noted that Agriprocessors' slaughter techniques had
been the subject of a 2004 undercover video by People for the Ethical
Treatment of Animals. The U.S. Department of Agriculture's
investigation of the company for alleged violations of the Humane
Slaughter Act was concluded last year, and the U.S. attorney's office
declined to prosecute.
RNS said the
USDA had released a report finding violations of the act, but the
document -- an investigator's internal memo -- actually had been
obtained by PETA through a Freedom of Information Act request.
The news service also reported that animal welfare expert Temple
Grandin had not been allowed to visit the Agriprocessors facility in
the wake of the video, but Grandin had visited the plant as a paid
consultant to Agriprocessors in June of this year and said that what
she saw then was working very well.
Also, RNS reported that a PETA spokesman said Agriprocessors refused to
allow inspectors to verify that it changed its slaughter techniques.
But Agriprocessors spokesman Mike Thomas said the facility had passed
four audits by outside animal-treatment auditors in the past year, and
USDA personnel are at the facility every day it is in operation.
Although community members and others have claimed that Agriprocessors'
work force is largely undocumented, Thomas said all prospective
employees are required to document their immigration status.
The RNS article reported that Agriprocessors, with six citations,
accounted for more than half the violations cited this year at Iowa
meatpacking plants by the Occupational Safety and Health
Administration. OSHA statistics, however, show there were 15 citations
at the four plants inspected so far, making Agriprocessors' share less
than half. Link