This past Saturday, Canada's National Post published a letter from an Israeli law professor. Anyone with some knowledge of Hebrew, however, could see that the professor was a phony. His signed name translates to "son of a bastard." Norman Spector, the former publisher of the Jerusalem Post, took note of the gaffe on his blog, calling it "one of the oldest hoaxes in the newspaper business." The Toronto Star's Antonia Zerbisias, who writes the best media blog in Canada, received an email from someone claiming to be the hoaxster. He/she says the Post was targeted because:
...WE WANT TO DESTROY THE CREDIBILITY OF THE NATIONAL POST BY
THEIR PRINTING FALSE LETTERS, WHICH HAS ALREADY SUFFERED PLAGIARISM,
FABRICATION OF STORIES AND RAPIDLY DECLINING CIRCULATION.
Here's some info on plagiarism and fabrication at the Post. It's interesting to see that a group who disagrees with the ideological slant of a newspaper immediately cites its lack of accuracy and credibility as justification for criticism. This, of course, is nothing new. But it drives home the point that striving for -- and maintaining -- the highest level of accuracy and ethical reporting is the first line of defense for the media. Errors and plagiarism arm partisan critics with easy ammunition.
This isn't to suggest the goal is to silence all criticism and debate; it's about having a debate focused on issues and ideas, rather than process.
Here's the letter in question:
Re: It's Now Up To The Palestinians, editorial, Sept. 13.
I
would like to add to your fine editorial about the ball being in
Palestinian hands. There must be rule of law in Gaza, and not the
looting and the utter chaos we have seen in the last few days.
Otherwise Western countries, and Israel, will see no need to create an
independent Palestinian state in Gaza and the West Bank.
Gaza,
where unemployment is rampant, will have to attract foreign investors,
yet they will be deterred by its lawlessness. Gaza authorities, as they
observe other Arab countries, have a stark choice -- imitating the
collapsing country of Iraq and the failed state of Somalia or pursue
democracy as in Lebanon. Canada, whose constitution and jurists are
renowned throughout the world, should send its experts to help rebuild
Gaza.
Ben Mamzer, Professor of Law, Faculty of Law, Hebrew University, Jerusalem.